Auditing & Error-Proofing: Flag Payments Just Under The Approval Limit

Excel Formulas › Auditing & Error-Proofing

All versions

Payments clustered just below an approval limit can mean someone is avoiding review. An IF with AND checks whether an amount falls inside a narrow band under the limit, so only the suspicious ones are listed for follow-up.


Quick formula: Flag amounts inside the band just under the limit:
=IF(AND(B2<C2,B2>=C2*(1-D2)),"Review","OK")

A $4,850 payment against a $5,000 limit with a 5% band is flagged Review.

Functions used (tap for the full reference guide):

The example

Three worked examples. Change any yellow input in the practice workbook and the results recalculate.

ABCDEF
1CaseAmountLimitBandFlagGap to limit
2Pay 1$4,850$5,0005.0%Review$150
3Pay 2$3,200$5,0005.0%OK$1,800
4Pay 3$4,990$5,0005.0%Review$10

The formula

Here is the formula, built directly from the inputs:

=IF(AND(B2<C2,B2>=C2*(1-D2)),"Review","OK") // Flag; Gap to limit

How it works

Here is the logic, one piece at a time:

  1. B2<C2 keeps amounts under the limit.
  2. C2*(1-D2) is the bottom of the band.
  3. AND requires both.
  4. C2-B2 shows the gap.

Keep every number in its own input cell so the formula never needs editing.

Try it: interactive demo

Interactive

Enter the values below.

Variations

Count flagged

Total flagged payments.

=COUNTIF(E2:E500,"Review")

Same vendor total

Sum by vendor.

=SUMIF(A2:A500,A2,B2:B500)

Pitfalls & errors

Also test sums per vendor per day, not just single payments.

Use a percent band as a decimal (0.05).

Review the vendor list, not just the amounts.

Practice workbook

Frequently asked questions

Does this prove fraud?
No, it only prioritizes review.
What band should I use?
Start with 5% and tune.

Stop fighting formulas. Learn them in a day.

This recipe is one of hundreds of real-world formulas we teach. Our Excel Formulas & Functions class covers lookups, logic, text, and dynamic arrays hands-on — live in Dallas–Fort Worth, Houston, Austin, Oklahoma City, Denver, or online.

See the Formulas & Functions Class

Related formulas: Reconcile Two Lists (Find Mismatches) · Cross-Foot Check (Totals Tie) · Flag Out-of-Range Values

Function references: IFAND